Date: November 24, 2008 1:15:13 PM PST
Subject: #twiki_release log

[12:06pm]peterthoeny:hi markus, are you at the keyboard?
[12:07pm]peterthoeny:i am expecting sopan to join, but it is an impossible time for him
[12:07pm]peterthoeny:we will probably shift the meeting time
[12:17pm] SamHasler joined the chat room.
[12:17pm] SamHasler left the chat room.
[12:19pm] foswiki_user joined the chat room.
[12:20pm] SopanShewale joined the chat room.
[12:21pm]peterthoeny:hi sopan, markus
[12:21pm]peterthoeny:who is foswiki_user?
[12:21pm]SopanShewale:Hi Peter
[12:22pm]peterthoeny:could you please introduce yourself?
[12:23pm]SopanShewale:Hi Markus
[12:23pm]SopanShewale:hi foswiki_user/foswiki_users
[12:23pm]peterthoeny:the info points to astro.cornell.edu
[12:25pm]peterthoeny:it might be don, not sure
[12:25pm]peterthoeny:anyway, we welcome anyone who would like to participate
[12:26pm]peterthoeny:unlike in other channels where twiki community members get banned
[12:26pm]peterthoeny:time check: +26
[12:26pm]peterthoeny:let's make this a short meeting
[12:26pm]peterthoeny:i can facilitate
[12:26pm]peterthoeny:who is taking notes?
[12:27pm]peterthoeny:proposed agenda:
[12:27pm]peterthoeny:# 0. Identify Suitable Time for Release Meeting
[12:27pm]peterthoeny:# 1. Review Urgent Bugs - for TWiki 4.2.4
[12:28pm]peterthoeny:let's start
[12:28pm]SopanShewale:on #0 - can be have meeting at 17:30 UTC?
[12:28pm]peterthoeny:---++ 0. Identify Suitable Time for Release Meeting
[12:28pm]SopanShewale:a few hrs before than the current time
[12:29pm]peterthoeny:that would work for me
[12:29pm]peterthoeny:that is 2.5 hours earlier than current meeting start
[12:30pm]SopanShewale:yes
[12:30pm]peterthoeny:if i calculate properly, 9:30am pst my time
[12:30pm]peterthoeny:any other proposal on meeting time?
[12:31pm]peterthoeny:if not, let's use 17:30 gmt from next time on, also for #twiki_marketing
[12:32pm]SopanShewale: ok
[12:32pm]peterthoeny:---++ 1. Review Urgent Bugs - for TWiki 4.2.4
[12:32pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/ReleaseBlocker
[12:32pm]SopanShewale:opening http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/ReleaseBlocker
[12:32pm]peterthoeny:let's look at the list sorted by id:
[12:32pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/ReleaseBlocker?sortcol=0;table=1;up=0#sorted_table
[12:33pm]SopanShewale:actually i have some list - let me run through my list peter
[12:33pm]peterthoeny:ok, please go ahead
[12:34pm]SopanShewale:Item6082  deep recursion bug in query search  Engine  Urgent  Confirmed  - This is fixed
[12:34pm]peterthoeny:i have seen
[12:34pm]peterthoeny:cool!
[12:34pm]peterthoeny:thank you sopan
[12:34pm]SopanShewale:Item6127  Total number of votes cannot be summed up for select options.  Extension VotePlugin  
  Urgent   New
[12:35pm]SopanShewale:*THIS CAN BE EASY TO FIX - I guess people have already provided solution in dev topic.
[12:35pm]SopanShewale: Need to sync the discussion and co-ordinate check-in*
[12:35pm]SopanShewale:i can take care of this one
[12:36pm]peterthoeny:is that a core fix needed for plugin?
[12:36pm]SopanShewale:no
[12:36pm]SopanShewale:this needs fix in VotePlugin - not really urgent
[12:36pm]peterthoeny:ah, ok
[12:36pm]SopanShewale:is not a blocker..
[12:37pm]peterthoeny:let's focus on release blockers for 4.2.4 release
[12:37pm]peterthoeny:(on this meeting)
[12:37pm]SopanShewale:i thin all Bugs which are marked "urgent" appear in Blockers
[12:37pm]SopanShewale:any way - next
[12:37pm]peterthoeny:yes
[12:37pm]SopanShewale:Item6008  EditTablePlugin returns to viewauth page after save  Engine EditTablePlugin  
  Urgent  New  05 Nov 2008 - 00:05
[12:37pm]SopanShewale:this is not a blocker
[12:37pm]peterthoeny:agreed
[12:37pm]SopanShewale:this is bug in "trunk"
[12:38pm]SopanShewale:and not in the release branch code
[12:38pm]peterthoeny:i suggest to add this to the subject of all trunk only bugs: .......... (trunk only)
[12:38pm]SopanShewale:this is issue in "Response.pm" .. this module is introduced very recently
[12:39pm]SopanShewale:*NO Action Required for this release"
[12:39pm]SopanShewale:I think i am Item5967  viewfile partly broken  Engine  Urgent  Confirmed  27 Oct 2008 - 14:28
[12:39pm]SopanShewale:i think i can handle this one too
[12:41pm]SopanShewale:shall i move to next one
[12:41pm]SopanShewale:?
[12:41pm]peterthoeny:i am wondering if this is urgent
[12:41pm]peterthoeny:a fix must be done carefully since it might break other things
[12:42pm]SopanShewale:yes.. this is related to "subwebs" - needs to be handled very carefully
[12:42pm]peterthoeny:it is urgent, but may be not a blocker for 4.2.4
[12:42pm]peterthoeny:we have lots of fixed already waiting to be released
[12:42pm]peterthoeny:i would say fix "as time permits"
[12:43pm]SopanShewale:ok
[12:43pm]peterthoeny:next?
[12:43pm]SopanShewale:Item6095: Registration confirmation page fails to display when user confirmation e-mail can't be sent
[12:43pm]SopanShewale:-- TWiki:Main.TimotheLitt - 23 Oct 2008
[12:43pm]SopanShewale:Already analysed nicely by TimotheLitt
[12:43pm]SopanShewale:*Just need to incorporate his patch/checkin into appropriate place*
[12:44pm]peterthoeny:ok
[12:44pm]SopanShewale:i can take care of this
[12:44pm]peterthoeny:sounds good
[12:45pm]peterthoeny:next?
[12:45pm]SopanShewale:next is
[12:45pm]SopanShewale:Item6091: statistics broken (trunk only)
[12:45pm]SopanShewale:*This does not affect current patch release*
[12:45pm]SopanShewale:Verified on develop.twiki.org - Thats a bug
[12:45pm]peterthoeny:yes
[12:45pm]SopanShewale:its issue on trunk - verified
[12:46pm]SopanShewale:needs to be verify on release branch - but my guess - it will work on release
[12:46pm]SopanShewale:again this is issues because of "Response.pm"
[12:46pm]peterthoeny:ok
[12:46pm]SopanShewale:not a release blocker
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:Item6086: TSA DENYTOPICVIEW causes crash
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:*This does not affect current patch release*
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:-- TWiki:Main.GilmarSantosJr - 21 Oct 2008  has worked on
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:but did not commit the code yet.
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:If he does not commit - then some one needs to work on this.
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:This is because of Addition of Response.pm
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:this is - not a release Blocker
[12:47pm]peterthoeny:ok
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:I am moving to next bug
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:Item5920: TWikiGroups shows all members twice
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:Issue with %GROUPS%
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:Not able to recreate this one...
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:Not urgent...
[12:47pm]SopanShewale:not a release Blocker
[12:47pm]peterthoeny:yes
[12:48pm]peterthoeny:reprio as normal
[12:48pm]SopanShewale:ok - i am moving to http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/ReleaseBlocker?sortcol=0;table=1;up=0#sorted_table topic
[12:48pm]SopanShewale:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item4688
[12:49pm]peterthoeny:i'd say defer to after 4.2.4, but to be fixed in 4.2 branch
[12:49pm]SopanShewale:ok.. so target next release/patch release?
[12:50pm]peterthoeny:yes
[12:50pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5437 - UTF-8 fixes for TWiki 5.0
  (was 4.2 but deferred)
[12:50pm]peterthoeny:this should be fixed in trunk only i think
[12:50pm]SopanShewale:target next release
[12:51pm]SopanShewale:yes
[12:51pm]peterthoeny:time check: +50 min
[12:51pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5804 is trunk only
[12:51pm]SopanShewale:Response.pm candidate
[12:51pm]SopanShewale:next release
[12:52pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5859 - Plugin does not work if using NTLM
[12:52pm]peterthoeny:i'd say reprio to normal until a developer can confirm
[12:52pm]SopanShewale:TinyMCE - this still required?
[12:52pm]SopanShewale:not release or may be ignore - i can't see this on Linux installations
[12:53pm]peterthoeny:yes, required, that is our wysiwyg editor (kupu is retired)
[12:53pm]SopanShewale:ah-sorry (was confused)
[12:53pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5860 - RcsWrap error problems can lead
  to incorrectly locked rcs ,v files
[12:54pm]peterthoeny:let's reprio this one to normal
[12:54pm]peterthoeny:seems a special case
[12:54pm]SopanShewale:ah.. this one is interesting
[12:54pm]peterthoeny:and no fix by reporter
[12:55pm]SopanShewale:any way - will be difficult to recreate it.. .. candidate for next release
[12:55pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5865 - TablePlugin should support
  rowspan from header row
[12:55pm]SopanShewale:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5865 - we already covered.. fixed
[12:56pm]SopanShewale:fixed today
[12:56pm]peterthoeny:yes, thank you sopan!
[12:56pm]peterthoeny:good approach to remove thead for now
[12:56pm]peterthoeny:we talked about Item5920, group member twice
[12:56pm]SopanShewale:thx..I think its not required-but if its really required - may be reporter (viki) can re-open it
[12:57pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5926 - Topics with Chinese in UTF8
  destroys page view in Internet Explorer
[12:57pm]SopanShewale:not sure what to do about 5926
[12:58pm]peterthoeny:i think it should be fixed in the 4.2 branch, but not for 4.2.4
[12:58pm]SopanShewale: need to learn Chinese
[12:58pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5943 - TWikiRegistrationAgent should
  be in Main's ALLOWWEBCHANGE by default
[12:59pm]SopanShewale:ah.. this is very rare case
[12:59pm]peterthoeny:i think this is a no-brainer, should fix for 4.2.4
[12:59pm]SopanShewale:not urgent Peter
[12:59pm]SopanShewale:not a blocker
[1:00pm]peterthoeny:agreed, not a blocker, but a one line change in main.webpreferences that is safe
[1:00pm]SopanShewale:ok.. can be handled very easily
[1:00pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5955 - WysiwygPlugin failes to
  roundtrip tables that are created with align center
[1:00pm]SopanShewale:do you want me to handle this one?
[1:00pm]SopanShewale:do you want me to handle this one? - Item5943?
[1:01pm]peterthoeny:yes please
[1:01pm]peterthoeny:on table roundtrip, this looks like some work
[1:01pm]SopanShewale:ok
[1:01pm]peterthoeny:i'd say, to be fixed in 4.2 branch, but defer to after 4.2.4
[1:02pm]SopanShewale:let us target next release for this one
[1:02pm]SopanShewale:yes
[1:02pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5957 - htdigest format password file
  gets stomped on password or email change/reset
[1:03pm]SopanShewale:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5957 - i  think i will take care of this
[1:03pm]SopanShewale:this one is interesting to work on
[1:03pm]SopanShewale:if its more work - may be we can push into next release
[1:03pm]peterthoeny:this is somewaht higher risk
[1:04pm]SopanShewale:ah - patch is available
[1:04pm]peterthoeny:i'd say fix in 4.2 branch, possibly defer after 4.2.4
[1:04pm]SopanShewale:i will review the patch
[1:04pm]SopanShewale:if its good -then  let us try to release now
[1:04pm]SopanShewale:i will handle this one
[1:04pm]peterthoeny:ok
[1:04pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5960 - Content-length breaks HTTP
  headers, a.o. pound fail results
[1:05pm]peterthoeny:it looks like this one needs some more research
[1:05pm]peterthoeny:definitely defer to after 4.2.4
[1:05pm]SopanShewale:this will revolve around Response.pm
[1:06pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item5967 - viewfile partly broken
[1:06pm]peterthoeny:what about this one?
[1:06pm]SopanShewale:this we discussed
[1:06pm]peterthoeny:ah, yes
[1:06pm]SopanShewale:i will try to attempt this one
[1:07pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item6032 - moving a topic accross webs
  destroys its twikiform
[1:07pm]SopanShewale:already similar one we worked on - Office2007 format failing
[1:07pm]peterthoeny:i'd say reprio to normal
[1:07pm]peterthoeny:seldom case
[1:07pm]peterthoeny:Item6039 is trunk only
[1:08pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item6041 - TinyMCE? bug with Firefox 3 and
  bulleted lists
[1:08pm]peterthoeny:a must fix, but i'd say defer to after 4.2.4
[1:08pm]peterthoeny:what do you think?
[1:08pm]SopanShewale:yes..next release
[1:09pm]peterthoeny:Item6086 - we talked about
[1:09pm]SopanShewale:yes
[1:09pm]peterthoeny:Item6091 - trunk only
[1:09pm]SopanShewale:we talked about that too
[1:09pm]peterthoeny:Item6095 - Registration confirmation page fails to display when user confirmation e-mail can't be sent
[1:10pm]SopanShewale:we talked about that oo
[1:10pm]SopanShewale:we talked about that too
[1:10pm]peterthoeny:yes
[1:10pm]peterthoeny:http://develop.twiki.org/~twiki4/cgi-bin/view/Bugs/Item6128 - Login names with dots not working properly
[1:10pm]SopanShewale:6128 - we already talked
[1:11pm]peterthoeny:yes
[1:11pm]SopanShewale:not a issue -we can happily close that
[1:11pm]peterthoeny:that's it
[1:11pm]SopanShewale:yup
[1:11pm]peterthoeny:anything else sopan?
[1:11pm]SopanShewale:About Bugs..thats all
[1:11pm]peterthoeny:anything else?
[1:12pm]SopanShewale:nope
[1:12pm]peterthoeny:ok, let's close the meeting
[1:12pm]SopanShewale:ok... thx
[1:12pm]peterthoeny:participants: sopan, peter
[1:12pm]SopanShewale:bye
[1:13pm]peterthoeny:silent observers: cornell univ person and markus
[1:13pm]peterthoeny:gotta go to visit a client
[1:13pm]peterthoeny:ttyl sopan
[1:13pm]SopanShewale:bye
[1:13pm]peterthoeny:and thanks!
[1:13pm]peterthoeny:good night
[1:13pm] SopanShewale left the chat room. ("ChatZilla 0.9.84 [Firefox 3.0.4/2008102920]")
[1:13pm]peterthoeny:i'll post the logs